A meta-analysis of 29 controlled-feeding studies sheds new light on the relation between macronutrient composition and total energy expenditure, according to a recent study published in The Journal of Nutrition.
The concept of energy balance and body weight regulation states that when energy intake is greater than energy expenditure excess calories are stored in the body with a subsequent increase in body weight. In this view, diets of equal caloric value but having differing ranges of macronutrient composition from very-low-carbohydrate to very-low fat should yield similar physiological impact. However, how the body uses calories is not that simple according to lead author David Ludwig (Harvard Medical School) and coauthors, which may account for divergent findings among studies.
The effect of macronutrient composition on total energy expenditure remains controversial, according to the study authors. “One possible explanation for this inconsistency may be study duration as a physiological adaptation to lower carbohydrate intake may require 2 to 3 weeks.”
To test the hypothesis that the effects of carbohydrates, expressed as a percent of energy intake on total energy expenditure vary with time, study results from a previous meta-analysis and those identified in new trials were analyzed. The duration of the studies, which included 617 participants, ranged from 1 to 140 days, with the difference in carbohydrate intake from 8% to 77%.
Among the 23 shorter trials (< 2.5 weeks), total energy expenditure was slightly reduced on lower-carbohydrate diets. In contrast, the longer duration lower-carbohydrate diet substantially increased total energy expenditure. It was estimated that these diets increased energy expenditure by ∼50 kcal per day for every 10% decrease in carbohydrates (expressed as % energy intake).
Upcoming ASN Webinar: Research Designs to Account for Diversity and Inclusiveness and Impact Food Guidance Policy
March 11, 2022, 12:30 – 2:00 PM EST
This webinar focuses on the consideration of diversity and inclusion when conducting research to inform and implement food and nutrition guidance policy. This webinar is part of the CASP Nutrition Policy Webinar series, designed to help ASN members better understand the interface between research and nutrition policy.
The authors conclude that contradictory findings of diets with different macronutrient compositions on total energy expenditure appear to arise, in part, from differences in study duration. These results highlight the importance of longer trials to understand chronic macronutrient effects and to better understand mechanisms whereby lower-carbohydrate diets may facilitate weight loss.
A corresponding editorial provides further perspective regarding the optimal diet composition for body-weight control. Researchers Faidon Magkos and Arne Astrup (University of Copenhagen) stress the importance of experimental testing in humans to better understand the metabolic nuances and interrelations between diet composition, metabolic fuel availability, body composition, and energy expenditure at various stages of the natural course of obesity.
Ludwig DS, Dickinson SL, Henschel B, Ebbeling CB, Allison DB. Do Lower-Carbohydrate Diets Increase Total Energy Expenditure? An Updated and Reanalyzed Meta-Analysis of 29 Controlled-Feeding Studies. The Journal of Nutrition, Volume 151, Issue 3, March 2021, Pages 482–490, https://doi.org/10.1093/jn/nxaa350.
Magkos F, Astrup A. Dietary Carbohydrate, Energy Expenditure, and Weight Loss: Is Eating Less and Burning More Possible? The Journal of Nutrition, Volume 151, Issue 3, March 2021, Pages 468–470, https://doi.org/10.1093/jn/nxaa423.
Images via canva.com.